Why Cheap 2011s Fail: MAC 9 DS Range Report
Welcome back to Jim’s Armory. This is Season 1, Episode 2 of Jim’s Gun Garage. In the last episode, Jim picked the MAC 9 DS Comp as the gun that gets a complete rebuild and upgrade – and gave it a name: the Turkato. Before he touches a single part, he takes it to the range as-is to get a baseline for how it feels and runs. It doesn’t take long for the problems to show up, and Jim uses them to explain why budget 2011s so often fail.
First Shots: Failure to Lock Back Right away, the slide doesn’t lock back on an empty magazine, and that keeps happening all day. Jim doesn’t consider that so much a malfunction as an inconvenience. It’s almost always a magazine issue – weak springs, or a fouled-up follower not catching the slide lock. In this case, though, Jim thinks the cause is his own thumb. The MAC 9 has an extended slide release, which is great for smaller hands, but Jim’s big thumb ends up resting right on it.
Pro-Tip: The right way to shoot a 2011 is with your thumb on top of the safety, so you don’t accidentally bump the safety back on while firing. If you have a big thumb, that means it may reach over the safety and rest on the slide lock – which can keep the slide from locking back.
Stovepipes and NATO 9mm Next comes a stovepipe. Jim credits longtime viewer Thomas for pointing out that in Turkey, they shoot NATO rounds, which are closer to +P, so guns built there tend to run heavier springs. Add the habit of budget 2011 makers to install much heavier recoil and hammer springs to cover for poor tolerances and heavy disconnector hang-up, and Jim says you’ve got a recipe for stovepipes. There isn’t enough energy to cycle the slide all the way back, so the case barely ejects while the slide is already heading forward again.
Failure to Extract The Turkato then throws a failure to extract that causes a double feed. Jim’s fix on the line: drop the mag, work the slide, and get back in. He jokes that it’s one of his favorite malfunctions because it’s so dramatic, but on a newer gun it’s almost never serious, and he’s confident it’s the extractor.
Jim sees this problem a lot, and not just on budget guns. In his view, the extractor is probably the number one issue. An internal extractor isn’t a bad thing – it just takes patience to set up correctly. The trouble is that it’s tempting for a budget maker to skip that step, and at this price point he suspects these guns are put together and boxed without much testing. He promises to show how to fit one later in the series.
Americanizing a Turkish Gun While shooting, Jim lands on the plan for the build: turn this Turkish gun into an American gun, using made-in-America internal parts. He has had the gun for about six months and bought the internals four or five months ago, so he’s glad to finally get it on the filming schedule. The idea also gave him another idea he teases as a surprise for the next episode.
What It’s Like When It Runs When it does run, Jim actually enjoys shooting it, and he likes how it looks. The lightning cuts are big and aggressive – big enough that you could stick your thumb in one and burn it on the barrel. The downsides are clear, though. The recoil spring feels like 16 pounds or more, and the trigger has a terrible reset and feels heavy – Jim guesses around 4.5 to 5 pounds. He says he’ll fix that.
Disappointing, But Common Jim points out that new-gun problems are frustrating but not unusual. He’s had issues with nearly every gun on his bench: a failure to return to battery on the SIG, the front sight falling off the Atlas on its first outing, a failure to return to battery and a badly damaged extractor on the Staccato, and a lock-back issue on the Masterpiece Arms. The Romulus is the one he doesn’t remember having trouble with. None of this discourages him; he expects all of it to be easy to fix.
The Promise of a 2011 Jim explains what you’re really paying for. A 1911 or 2011 has very close tolerances and only a few moving parts riding on small pins – the trigger bow pushes directly on the sear, which pivots and releases the hammer. Makers can only cut costs in a few ways: time (labor), materials, or both. Hand fitting, especially of the extractor, is one shortcut you can’t take. Done right, a 2011 gives you a crisp trigger and a buttery slide, and for anyone coming from striker-fired guns, it can be eye-opening.
Final Thoughts In Jim’s view, the Turkato robs you of that promise: cheap parts, a poorly fitted extractor, and super heavy springs to make up for it all. As he puts it, if you can’t air rack it, it isn’t a real 2011. The rebuild starts next episode – subscribe and stay tuned for Jim’s Gun Garage.
